When choosing the right forklift for your operation, one of the biggest decisions is whether to go electric or internal combustion (IC). Both electric and IC forklifts offer distinct advantages, but understanding their differences is essential to selecting the right equipment for your application. From operating costs and maintenance requirements to performance and versatility, several factors should be considered when determining which forklift best meets your needs.
Electric forklifts continue to gain popularity as technological advancements expand their capabilities. With electric forklifts now accounting for more than 70% of the forklift market, innovations in battery technology, fast-charging capabilities, and performance enhancements are helping deliver the power, runtime, and efficiency needed for demanding operations. These advancements are making electric forklifts an increasingly viable alternative to traditional internal combustion (IC) forklifts across a wide range of applications.
With these advantages come other factors to consider. Although electric forklifts have lower lifetime fuel costs, their initial costs are higher. In addition to the cost of the battery, some operations require an area for charging, watering, and cleaning. Many forklifts are designed to protect critical components from water intrusion that could cause damage.
The market for IC forklifts remains strong. They account for about 30% of the forklift market and are viable solutions for both indoor and outdoor applications. IC forklifts tend to be more popular for constant operations with little to no downtime.
Other factors to consider include:
If your operation does not require an IC forklift, then the benefits of reduced maintenance, repairs, and fuel costs might outweigh the increased upfront cost.
If you are located in an area that does not have gasoline or diesel refilling stations readily available, LP is an ideal choice. If you are purchasing forklifts for a new facility, LP has the lowest initial cost. All you need to purchase are LP tanks and a place to store them. LP tanks have to be stored outdoors in a locked storage container and labeled with proper hazard signs. LP tanks can also be changed in a matter of minutes, reducing your downtime when refueling. LP forklifts are available with both cushion and pneumatic tires and are ideal for both indoor and outdoor operations.
Dual fuel offers the flexibility of operating on both gasoline and LP, allowing operators to switch between fuel types based on availability and application needs. The versatility can help minimize downtime by ensuring a backup fuel option is always accessible. While they may require the infrastructure to support both fuel types, they can provide operational convenience for mixed-use fleets. The added complexity of maintaining two fuel systems may increase service considerations compared to single-fuel options.
Diesel fuel is highly efficient and can provide longer run times compared to other fuel types. A by-product of diesel combustion is soot, which can accumulate in a forklift's exhaust system and needs to be removed. In general, diesel engines also have higher torque than their LP or gas counterparts, which can provide increased gradeability and acceleration. Though diesel traditionally costs more per gallon than gasoline, it can provide a better return on investment over the years of use. Diesel-powered forklifts are only available with pneumatic tires and are designed for outdoor use.
IC forklifts perform well in outdoor environments but can have difficulty maneuvering in tight spaces. However, electric forklifts excel in small, indoor spaces.
Service requirements vary between electric and IC forklifts, depending on the components that power each. With fewer moving parts, Toyota’s Electric Forklifts usually require less routine maintenance. Toyota’s IC Forklifts require more frequent maintenance due to their powerful engines. Following the recommended maintenance schedule for either power source can support reliable, long-lasting performance.
Request a consultation from your authorized Toyota dealer to help you determine which forklift(s) would work best for your operation. Our forklift experts will work directly with your business to determine the best option(s) to tackle whatever challenges you might be facing.